BroadbandNow is supported by commissions from some of the providers listed on our site. Learn More

EarthLink vs. AT&T Internet

Compare EarthLink and AT&T Internet internet service in 2024

8 Plans Available
EarthLink internet
price range
$39.95 - $189.95/month
*Prices may vary depending on the plan.

PROVIDER DETAILS

  • Download speeds up to: 5 Gbps
  • DSL, Fixed Wireless, Fiber
  • Unlimited Data
8 Plans Available
AT&T internet
price range
$55 - $245/month
*Prices may vary depending on the plan.

PROVIDER DETAILS

  • Download speeds up to: 5 Gbps
  • IPBB, Fiber, Fixed Wireless
  • Unlimited Data

Learn more about EarthLink and AT&T:

Learn more about EarthLink and AT&T

EarthLink and AT&T rank as premium internet providers in the U.S., both offering fiber-optic internet in addition to DSL connections, which are an alternative perfect for rural areas. As the second-largest DSL provider in the country, EarthLink provides DSL, wireless, and fiber internet options that are available across a cumulative 26 states. With EarthLink, you can expect speeds up to 5 Gbps. EarthLink only offers home phone service in a bundle option.

AT&T is the largest provider of Internet Protocol Broadband (IPBB) and fiber broadband in the U.S., covering 21 states. AT&T also offers 5G home internet and fixed wireless connections. Customers can bundle AT&T with home phone and AT&T’s wireless cellular services. AT&T Fiber tops out at speeds up to 5 Gbps.

EarthLink vs AT&T: Best Deals

Internet Deals

EarthLink and AT&T Have Similar Fee Structures

Both EarthLink and AT&T Internet Offer Self-Installation

While many internet service providers (ISPs) charge hefty fees for professional installation of internet services, both EarthLink and AT&T allow you to self-install your own internet and save money along the way. Certain situations may require professional installation, but CenturyLink and AT&T usually waive this fee for new subscribers.

AT&T Internet Doesn’t Require Annual Contracts

Many EarthLink internet plans require a one-year contract with early-termination fees (ETFs) that can reach $200. Additional fees may apply, such as installation, shipping of equipment, and local taxes. Depending on the plan selected, EarthLink customers may be required to rent a modem for an additional $12.95 per month. AT&T doesn’t require annual contracts, and it doesn’t hike your prices after a set number of months.

EarthLink Beats AT&T Internet in Data Caps With Unlimited Internet

There are no data caps on EarthLink’s internet plans (with the exception of EarthLink’s wireless services, which do have a soft data limit). AT&T has some data restrictions for DSL and fixed wireless plans.

EarthLink vs. AT&T Internet Review

We asked BroadbandNow users to review EarthLink based on four core attributes: Customer Service, Reliability, Speed, and Value.

BroadbandNow readers submitted 349 for EarthLink. EarthLink earned an average score of 4.08 out of 5.

We asked BroadbandNow users to review AT&T based on four core attributes: Customer Service, Reliability, Speed, and Value.

BroadbandNow readers submitted 3139 for AT&T. AT&T earned an average score of 3.39 out of 5.

Frequently Asked Questions About EarthLink and AT&T Internet Services

  • Is EarthLink or AT&T cheaper?

    AT&T is the more affordable option, with prices starting at $55 per month. In comparison, EarthLink plans start at $39.95 per month, which is slightly more expensive.

  • Who has faster speeds — EarthLink or AT&T Internet?

    AT&T offers speeds up to 5 Gbps with select fiber plans, which is faster than EarthLink’s top fiber speeds capable of reaching 5 Gbps. Access to these speeds depends on coverage availability and your location.

  • Do EarthLink and AT&T Internet have unlimited data?

    EarthLink offers unlimited data with its fiber and DSL internet plans, while its wireless plans have a soft data cap. AT&T offers unlimited internet on its fiber and 5G home internet plans, but not on its fixed wireless and IPBB plans.

  • Do EarthLink and AT&T require contracts?

    EarthLink requires a one-year contractual commitment from customers, while AT&T doesn’t require any contracts.